Science & technology | Generative AI

How generative models could go wrong

A big problem is that they are black boxes

In 1960 norbert wiener published a prescient essay. In it, the father of cybernetics worried about a world in which “machines learn” and “develop unforeseen strategies at rates that baffle their programmers.” Such strategies, he thought, might involve actions that those programmers did not “really desire” and were instead “merely colourful imitation[s] of it.” Wiener illustrated his point with the German poet Goethe’s fable, “The Sorcerer’s Apprentice”, in which a trainee magician enchants a broom to fetch water to fill his master’s bath. But the trainee is unable to stop the broom when its task is complete. It eventually brings so much water that it floods the room, having lacked the common sense to know when to stop.

Explore more

This article appeared in the Science & technology section of the print edition under the headline “How generative models could go wrong”

From the April 22nd 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition
A string of SpaceX StarLink satellites passes over an old stone house

Satellites are polluting the stratosphere

And forthcoming mega-constellations will exacerbate the problem

An illustration of hands and arms going through a nest of lines.

AI models are dreaming up the materials of the future

Better batteries, cleaner bioplastics and more powerful semiconductors await


Colossal woolly mouse

Mice have been genetically engineered to look like mammoths

They are small and tuskless, but extremely fluffy


Is posh moisturiser worth the money?

Don’t break the bank

How artificial intelligence can make board games better

It can iron out glitches in the rules before they go on the market

The skyrocketing demand for minerals will require new technologies

Flexible drills, distributed power systems and, of course, artificial intelligence