Leaders | Tilting at windfalls

Windfall taxes on energy companies are a bad idea

Governments should not seize the energy industry’s profits

WHENEVER OIL and gas are expensive, politicians’ eyes turn greedily to the profits of energy firms. Since energy prices began to surge last year Bulgaria, Italy, Romania and Spain have introduced new taxes on the industry. On March 8th the European Commission recommended that governments try to “capture a part of the returns” made by electricity generators. And in America 12 Democratic senators including Elizabeth Warren, a one-time presidential candidate, have proposed a tax on every barrel of oil big firms produce or import, equal to half the difference between the current oil price and the 2015-19 average.

This article appeared in the Leaders section of the print edition under the headline “Tilting at windfalls”

The alternative world order

From the March 19th 2022 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition
Friedrich Merz speaks during a press conference on planned major investments, in Berlin, Germany on March 4th 2025

A fantastic start for Friedrich Merz

The incoming chancellor signals massive increases in defence and infrastructure spending

A Team Dover Airman loads weapons cargo bound for Ukraine onto a C-17 Globemaster III during a security assistance mission at Dover Air Force Base, Delaware

The lesson from Trump’s Ukrainian weapons freeze

And the grim choice facing Volodymyr Zelensky


Ukrainian President Zelensky Visits Downing Street Ahead Of European Leaders Summit

Western leaders must seize the moment to make Europe safe

As they meet in London, Vladimir Putin will sense weakness


Prabowo Subianto takes a chainsaw to Indonesia’s budget

The result? More money for the president’s boondoggles

Inheriting is becoming nearly as important as working

More wealth means more money for baby-boomers to pass on. That is dangerous for capitalism and society