Briefing | Trans substantiation

The evidence to support medicalised gender transitions in adolescents is worryingly weak

The effectiveness and side-effects of the most common treatments are not well understood

PRISHA MOSLEY was 17 when she was first given testosterone in a clinic in North Carolina, after she had declared to her parents that she was a boy. She had struggled through her teen years with anorexia and depression after a sexual assault. Luka Hein had both breasts removed as a 16-year-old in Nebraska. Chloe Cole, in California, was a year younger when she had her double mastectomy. She had been on testosterone and puberty-blocking drugs since 13, also after a sexual assault.

This article appeared in the Briefing section of the print edition under the headline “Trans substantiation”

From the April 8th 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition
An illustration depicting a player holding a wild card and a pair of Aces, while Trump sits anxiously on the other side of the table.

The transactional world Donald Trump seeks would harm not help America

Ukraine, Gaza and China will all test his self-interested approach to diplomacy

A photo collage illustrating the chaos Trump is causing, featuring Trump, Eric Adams, Elon Musk, a plastic straw, Mt. McKinley, the USAID flag, the Kennedy Center DEI, and the transgender symbol.

Donald Trump is a reckless president, but not yet a lawless one

He has yet to flatly defy a court order, which would initiate a constitutional crisis


 Soldiers of the Ukrianian Armed Forces inspect FPV drones

America’s military supremacy is in jeopardy

To win future wars it needs new weapons, new suppliers and a new system of procurement


Online scams may already be as big a scourge as illegal drugs

And they are growing fast

Even in India, bureaucracy is being curtailed

Many small steps could make a big difference

Many governments talk about cutting regulation but few manage to

Yet radical deregulation is often a big boost to growth