Europe | Charlemagne

The EU’s response to the crisis in Israel exposes its limits

Whose foreign policy is it anyway?

Ursula von der Leyen, Emmanuel Macron and Olaf Scholz look on in dismay as a EU ceremonial trumpeter blows a discordant note against the backdrop of an ominous sky with smoke and explosions
Image: Peter Schrank

Nothing screams “great power” like an aircraft-carrier. And so on October 10th Thierry Breton, the European commissioner hailing from France, raised the idea of the EU availing itself of such a seafaring airbase. Alas, even before the merits of a floating jet-launcher for a bloc with neither navy nor air force could be considered, the EU’s geopolitical ambitions fared as poorly as a plane lurching off the deck and into the drink. In the days around Mr Breton’s flight of fancy, a fumbled response to the terrorist attacks in Israel on October 7th left Europe looking muddled. A union that had found its foreign-policy voice over Ukraine has rediscovered its penchant for cacophony. A bout of chaotic diplomacy and internal squabbling has set back the cause of a “geopolitical EU” to match China and America.

Explore more

This article appeared in the Europe section of the print edition under the headline “Back to cacophony”

From the October 21st 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition
A collage of Trump and on one side and Zelensky and Starmer huugging on the other. There are pieces of maps around too.

The dangerous tension in Europe’s response to Trump

By trying to stop the rift, Europe may hasten it

Illustration of Germany’s black eagle emblem with Friedrich Merz's head, his feathers are starting to get ratty and falling out

Can Friedrich Merz get Europe out of its funk?

A new Merz-mentum could reboot the Franco-German motor at the heart of the EU


Ukrainian soldiers fire with 2S22 Bohdana self-propelled howitzer on Russian positionin Donetsk Oblast, Ukraine

Can Europe keep Ukraine in the fight if America really has bailed?

Investing in Ukraine’s own weapons industry will be the best bet


The War Room newsletter: After the White House debacle, what next?

As Trump suspends military aid, what are the chokeholds on Ukraine?

The war-torn country can substitute some—but nothing like all—of the kit it gets from America

Europe vows to defend Ukraine, but prays for Trump’s support

A summit in London is stalked by the fear America will walk away